I've spent most of the past week glued to the computer and radio keeping up with Hurricane Katrina news. Haven't had much extra energy to put towards writing up a post. The one time that I did sit down and start typing I quickly realized I had nothing to say that would strike anyone as news ... feeling sad for the people in New Orleans, what's taking so long, ... now that some time has passed a couple thoughts keep running through my mind.
I keep thinking about the New Orleans Mayor, it seems to me he has gotten a bum rap. Further revelations about his performance may prove me wrong, but so far it strikes me that he did all he could with what he had available. I read one piece of commentary that criticized him for not rising to the level of Rudy Giuliani and taking charge of the situation. Not fair it seems to me, the Mayor of New York had the resources of a small nation at his finger tips visa vi the NYPD, NYFD and other city agencies, the feds simply came along side and filled in the gaps; Mayor Nagin as leader of the 25th largest city undoubtedly had many resources available to him, but New Orleans a very poor city, I'm guessing the resources available more in keeping with a city much smaller, surely not enough to even begin to handle evacuating and later rescuing the 100,000+ people who didn't own cars. He needed federal aid even before the hurricane hit to aid in the evacuation and properly staff the Superdome/Convention Center sites. Mayor Giuliani also had a functioning communication system, Mayor Nagin operating in a near communication blackout which undoubtedly made a bad situation 100 times worse. I do wonder why he waited so long to order the mandatory evacuation, interested to see as time goes on if this totally his own decision or if others pressured him to hold off. Having an extra day to evacuate the city and get a better handle on how many left behind would have surely made a big difference.
I've never had much patience for red tape. Of course, no one does. For myself I differentiate between the needed filling out forms and letting the process work its way through which I'm generally patient with vs. flat out CYA, protecting turf, hiding behind rules and other bureaucratic machinations that serve no purpose other than to hide incompetence, cover up mistakes, deflect responsibility or allow people to take it easy while at work. I'm definitely a spirit of the law kind of person and have endeavored to uphold this in the various jobs I've held. I'm also tend to go by the notion, "it's easier to apologize than ask permission". I think sometimes in my life I've carried this notion too far and have aimed in recent years to temper it a bit. As you might guess it kills me inside to hear all the reports of the muddled chain of command hindering the relief effort. "The governor didn't make an official request", "the request wasn't filled with the proper codes", "FEMA can't task military aircraft", "Defense Dept. and Justice Dept. lawyers debated the potential liability of National Guard troops trying to enforce local laws if President Bush used his authority to federalize all the Guard troops to speed the response", ... you get the idea. Usually just added inconvenience, in this case many lives lost and needlessly so. It would seem in times like these people would look past this stuff and get the job done in order to save lives in a crisis situation. I still find it hard to comprehend officials insisting on spending hours, sometimes days, hashing this stuff out with so many lives hanging in the balance.
Race. A couple days before the press started talking about it, it struck me that every picture of looting I saw featured black folk doing the looting. Soon after it struck me that every person I saw at the Superdome/Convention Center sites black, save one white nurse helping folks at the Convention Center. I don't believe those in power purposely abandoned the people in New Orleans because they are primarily black, on the other hand I'm not so naive as to think race and politics didn't play some role in the sluggish start to the relief effort. Look back to 9/11. President Bush and Rudy Giuliani both leaders in the same political party, probably not best friends, but surely they new each other on some level. You can bet the Mayor had no problem getting in touch with the President and having his ear when he needed to. Now envision Mayor Nagin trying to reach the White House, he's just another mayor to them, they've probably never met. Chances are he had trouble getting through and being taken seriously. I'm sure the President and the people around him care about the folks in New Orleans, just the same I'm guessing they didn't initially treat the hurricane and it's aftermath with the same degree of urgency and attention another part of the country might have received. Not because they are bigots, but because they don't have any day to day connection with this part of the country. Democrat Governor and Mayor, large poor black population, in other words it's not "family" the same way Florida would be with the President's brother, New York as our country's principle city, California with it's large population and influence, no, New Orleans just a "customer" of the federal government and got treated accordingly.